Hello, and Merry Christmas from New York City. My name is Matthew Daniel Thurman, and I have been invited by the curators to be the guest blogger for this Holiday edition. It means the world to me to contribute to such a valuable enterprise as this, and those of you that are familiar with my recent comments know that I love to discuss music, and all of the necessary factors involved. I love to argue, interrupt, force my opinions on others, and basically criticize anyone who's too stupid not to have the same incredibly wonderful taste in music that I do. Or in more modern terms, if you own a copy of Tina Turner's "Private Dancer", then I can't imagine why you would possibly like me, because I will spend countless hours listening to myself explain to you why you are wrong, and I am of course, right, when it comes to evaluating that album's merits and worth. Nonetheless, as I grow older, I find that nature has a way of making "bad music for bad people" much less of a threat, much less of a problem, much less of an annoyance, and discovering that you can indeed teach an old dog new tricks, I've decided that instead of shattering someone else's record collection before their very eyes, perhaps I could help them construct a new one...or, if that sounds a bit too arrogant, then perhaps a "new edition" or "new selections" will suffice. So, let me begin, by turning you on to something that you may feel you already know, or do you?
I grew up surrounded by a cassette culture. I never much cared for vinyl...still, don't really, and when you're a teenager growing up in the mountains, a boxful of tapes and a boombox are sometimes all you need to transport you above and beyond your own horizons. Eventually, if you embrace the world of cassettes as I did, then you slowly discover the "blank" cassette tape, which of course leads you to the "record" buttons, and suddenly, the lightbulb above your head heats up hotter than a thousand suns. Thus, your very first mix-tape is born, and the world will never be the same. How could it be? You have discovered the incredible power that resides within the DNA of an incredibly potent form of art known as the "Pop Song". Now, I love listening to albums in their entirety just as much as anyone, and some work better than others when digested as a whole: "Dark Side Of The Moon" being an obvious example...but this isn't about that. This is about the re-discovery of the simple, yet classic song. I think all of us here have been involved in some musical enterprise or another in terms of "creation", so songwriting is something that we have also probably grappled with, and will continue to do so. Keep in mind that this blog is limiting itself to the basic rock and roll song, so if you're next project is something a bit different...well, still, you might even pick up a few ideas contained wherein.
I like to study songs. I like to study lists. I like lists that have decided for themselves to inform me what the greatest rock and roll songs of all time are. We've all seen these lists...and we've all lost our minds over them. "What....'Love Will Tear Us Apart' by Joy Division is at 189, and 'Like A Virgin' is at 188?!? Are they completely out of their minds?!?" Still, the books, and lists exist, and they change and grow, but a few commonalities seem to persist. There seems to be no denying a really good pop song, they've become virtually indestructible. Interestingly, most of the lists seem to start with pretty much the same usual suspects:
1. Like A Rolling Stone
2.Satisfaction
3.Imagine
4.What's Goin' On?
5.Respect
6.Good Vibrations
7.Johnny B. Goode
8.Tutti Frutti
9.What'd I Say?
10. My Generation
Now, you can easily substitute "Hound Dog", "Blue Suede Shoes", "Mannish Boy", "I Wanna Hold Your Hand", "Gloria", "Louie, Louie", "Summertime Blues" or "Hey Joe" for any of the bottom selections and make a valid argument as to why it means as much. After the usual top ten, the field widens a bit, but still, a common thread remains: Lots of Beatles, Stones, Zeppelin, Who, the Doors, and a ton of Motown. (In fact, if you go out tonight and pick up a really comprehensive Motown or Stax/Volt set, then you'll automatically own several of the entries within these "Top 500 Of All Time" lists.) But then, something wonderful happens: a few gems emerge that maybe you've forgotten about, or maybe you just never have really got around to listening to...I mean, really listening to. "Walk On By" by Dionne Warwick. "Wichita Lineman" by Jimmy Webb". "Still Of The Night"-5 Satins, "Earth Angel"-Penguins, "Up On The Roof"-Drifters, "River Deep, Mountain High"-Ike and Tina Turner, "All I Have To Do Is Dream"-Everly Brothers, "I Only Have Eyes For You"-Flamingos, or even "Son Of A Preacher Man" by Dusty Springfield. And so on. Wonderful songs, all of them. And yeah, sure, the lists also include plenty of clunkers, which seem to rise and fall with the passage of time. A lot of these lists are compiled by contributors of all ages, so if a song is really hot at the time of the list's construction, it usually finds it's way in, only to drop out of sight 5-10 years later. "Hey Ya!" by OutKast could be a prime example. Let's see how time treats that one. But when
you really study these lists, as well as these songs, and I mean really study them...amazing things happen. Have you ever sat around listening to a few of your favorites, and then discovering that they were actually someone else's favorites...years and years before? The way the Velvet's "There She Goes Again" nicks the riff from Marvin Gaye's "Hitch-Hike" for example. I always loved the way Kim Gordon used to purr "I'm the boy that can enjoy invisibility"...until the day I discovered Serge Gainsbourg made the same declaration a few years before! And if you're thinking "Man, I've heard these songs a million times before...I'm sick of 'em, I need some new ideas"...better check yo'self before you wreck yo'self. Go back and grab a hold of "Honky Tonk Women"...a classic, that easily resounds within your own mind. Also a very simple song...nothing fancy whatsoever about it, right? Listen again, and really listen this time. Have you noticed anything yet? Have you noticed that there's NO BASS ON THE VERSES?!? When was the last time a pop hit ever tried that li'l trick? Have you ever tried it? The well is endless...endless, I'm telling you. Don't ever think you've got it covered, because I guarantee you, there's a pop hit out there somewhere that will give you a much needed breath of fresh air. And don't think for a minute that record sales are what determines these lists. "The Eagles Greatest Hits" is the best selling album of all time, but you won't find many of it's songs included in these lists. "Hotel California" might pop up on a few, but that one came after.
John Cramer mentioned in an earlier blog that he would consider getting back into recording, and maybe even public performance, if he could somehow or another align himself with individuals that shared his ideas. He also mentioned a desire to use the basic instruments of the rock canon, but instead maybe they could construct a new sound with no persistent melody, or chord changes, or a persistent pulse. Personally, I'd like to hear more about this, because I've found myself constantly thinking the same thoughts, and heading in the same directions, so I'm extremely interested as to what he has in mind. But I think even if you're searching for that music, music that perhaps is a bit more on the "free" side of things, or even the "noise" side, I still think you could pick up a few tips from some of these tried and true selections. Just as an example, Take a listen to "Stand By Me" by Ben E. King, and just marvel at how powerful that opening stand up bass figure really is. He's only playing 3 notes, over and over, with a little scratch from the percussion, and that's it, that's all there is, and then that first line "When the night has come, and the land is dark"...for my money, it's just as powerful, just as heavy as Peter Brotzmann's "Machine Gun"...I really don't hear the difference. Sometimes more is more, and sometimes the "less is more " way of thinking become united, as one. That's the whole point, here, really. That there aren't any rules as to what is the definition of a song, or what is the definition of music, itself, but I think if you re-evaluate these classic songs, and re-evaluate their structure, you might discover some really radical stuff, even if it is contained within the 3-minute format.
So do yourself a favor...take the Ayler, and Derek Bailey's, and the PIL's, and the Merzbow's, and just put 'em on the back shelf every once in awhile. Instead, sit down for an afternoon with a little bit of "Baker Street" by Gerry Rafferty. Or how 'bout a little "Magnet And Steel"-Walter Egan, "Sundown"-Gordon Lightfoot, "Mama Told Me Not To Come"-Three Dog Night, "Whatcha Gonna Do When She Says Goodbye?"-Pablo Cruise, "How Much I Feel"-Ambrosia, "Spooky"-Atlanta Rhythm Section, "Diamond Girl"-Seals and Crofts, "Magic"-Pilot, or "You're So Vain" by Carly Simon. And don't think for a minute that these are guilty pleasures. "Guilty Pleasures" is a phrase used by chickenshit punks that don't have the balls to stand up straight and tall, and declare "No, man...this ain't the Art Ensemble Of Chicago! This is "Jackie Blue" by The Ozark Mountain Daredevils! So see if you can get to that! Go to the bookstore and peruse the Billboard's chart hits from the 50's onward. There's plenty of this information, and it's easily available. And in this digital age of file sharing, and quick burning, locating a few of these forgotten gems can just be as easy as a few clicks of the mouse. And if you're married...well, for God's sake, get a divorce! Or at least have an affair...we're songwriters, aren't we? But if you're too cool for this music, or this way of thinking, well, that's okay too. Me, I'm gonna go put on the Ronette's "Be My Baby"...when that opening drum starts off with the BOOM-Bah-BOOM...BAP! BOOM-Bah-BOOM...Bap!...Ooooh, my soul! Merry Christmas, you old savings and loan! Merry Christmas, Mr. Potter! Merry Christmas, everyone!