Methodology of a Mix (Heidi substitution edition)
Basically, I make a new mix when I have noted enough songs that fit certain criteria to fill an 80 minute CD-R, with a couple extra tracks thrown in for the classic 90 minute cassette format. The main criterion for inclusion is that I have fallen in love with the song in the time period since the production of my previous mix. And I mean really fall in love, since the primary function of the mix is for repeated listening in my car, over and over and over again. Each song must be catchy enough for me to dig it in the first place, but must be substantive enough not to become annoying after 500 listens. I know for sure when a song should be included when I get home and just have to listen to a certain song at high volumes for like 20 times in a row, or go to a show and keep hearing that song in my head, wishing I were seeing it played on stage, or wake up and my brain has obviously been humming the song all night long.
Choosing a song becomes a bit more of a judgment call in cases where there's a really cool part that I fall in love with, but some other element to the song that maybe isn't so thrilling, or is perhaps even cheesy. I have become more adept in recent years at appreciating what good I can take from a song rather than letting some less savory aspect poison my view of it entirely, however. The song doesn't need to be a new song, but is usually new to me, although even this generalization has exceptions. Sometimes I have owned an album for years, such as U2's "Boy", and although I appreciated it, I never got to the infatuation stage until a couple years ago, with the song "The Electric Co.". Sometimes I really fall for an album, and so want to include it on a mix, but no one particular song presents itself as the obvious choice. And sometimes the selected song doesn't hold up as well by itself as it did as part of the whole album. And sometimes things aren't as clear as in the ideal situation. I may like a song a great deal, but haven't gone through the infinite-play rotation. Does it make the cut?
Above all, the purity of the selection process must be maintained. No notion of coolness, indie cred, or any similar concept can be permitted to enter into my thinking. Often I will listen to an album and really get into a song, then later find out that the song in question was released as a first single, and perhaps even became popular enough to merit a backlash from the forces of obscurantism. This cannot affect my decision either for or against. And then there are the matters of sequencing, editing, titling, and CD vs. cassette versions, but I've written enough for now. I'll leave you with a few words about the selections on the latest ConorMix(tm), just on the off chance it is of interest to anyone besides myself.
01. Yo La Tengo "Pass The Hatchet, I Think I'm Goodkind" (I Am Not Afraid Of You And I Will Beat Your Ass, 01)
This is a ten minute guitar jam/rave-up that totally rules. Saw them play this at Pitchfork, but didn't fully appreciate until I got the CD.
02. CSS "Alala" (Cansei De Ser Sexy, 03)
A dance jam by our too-sexy friends from South America. In the few seconds before the bass & keyboards kick in, it could almost be mistaken for some between-song Ultra Hummus rehearsal tape detritus, which I find hilarious.
03. Band of Horses "The Funeral" (Everything All the Time, 04)
Another band I saw at Pitchfork. All tension until the wall of guitars kicks in after a minute or so.
04. Billy Nicholls "Girl from New York" (Would You Believe, 11)
My friend KQ put this on one of his mixes, so I guess I kinda cheated a little, but hey this is an impossibly great little song. Billy Nicholls is a fairly obscure 60's dude you should check out. Great fuzz tone guitar on this one. I love putting this on repeat for about 25 times and trying to play along.
05. Ivy "Point of View" (Realistic, 06)
Warm and fuzzy but melancholic pop, French girl vocals, drifting away repeatedly. Was going to end the mix with this, but it seemed to work better here.
06. 27 Various "Shag" (Fine, 05)
Early 90's Minneapolis band that obviously listened to a My Bloody Valentine album or two. Had a dub of this on an old cassette (side A: Pavement "Slanted & Enchanted", side B: 27 Various "Fine") that I hadn't listened to in years, but randomly found a shrink-wrapped CD in a store up in Portland.
07. Lilys "Knocked on the Fortune Teller's Door" (Everything Wrong is Imaginary, 04)
From another fine album by the Lilys. This track is churning and dreamy, slightly claustrophobic.
08. Sinéad O'Connor "He Prayed" (Throw Down Your Arms, 04)
I got into Sinéad's gone-reggae album, but wasn't sure which song to use. This one perhaps sounds a bit too much like your standard issue reggae song, but even so I think that lends it a certain spareness that allows her vocals give you the chills.
08.5. Massive Attack "Spying Glass" (Protection, 05) [tape version only]
Now I'm wishing I had put this on the CD version too. I love the unusual stuttered vocal phrasing, and the similar techniques utilized in the backing parts. Each miniature explosion of sound creates of ripples of space around it.
09. Yeah Yeah Yeahs "Gold Lion" (Show Your Bones, 01)
One of those bands I was prepared to hate, but just couldn't deny.
10. The Shins "Sea Legs" (Wincing the Night Away, 05)
I had somehow ignored the Shins the past couple years, but have recently changed my ways. They have such great vocal melodies, for one thing. The electronic elements here fuse perfectly into the song.
11. 20 Minute Loop "Jubilation" (Decline of Day, 01)
I had wanted to put this on a mix for a long time, but only had an mp3 of it until recently. This is a well crafted song by a local Bay Area group. Seems like standard pop/rock at first, but something is slightly askew in a wonderful way. There are a couple drum breaks on here that are just perfect.
12. Polyphonic Spree "It's the Sun" (The Beginning Stages Of, 02)
Finally got around to hearing the Spree. This song is just like its lyrics. It feels like going out into the bright sunshine, stretching and seeing blue skies.
13. Eugene Kelly "Bridge from Eden" (Man Alive, 09)
Former Vaselines/Eugenius guy. This album has a few terrible songs, but also some really good ones. This one's kinda melancholic but beautiful. Sort of a classic rock sound on this one.
14. The Dears "Ballad of Humankindness" (Gang of Losers, 10)
This is another thing that sometimes happens with songs for me. I don't think I had ever listened to the Dears before, but heard this song on The Current 89.3 while driving into Minneapolis, and instantly decided it had to be on the next mix.
15. Sonic Youth "The Neutral" (Rather Ripped, 10)
SY's latest album is strong from start to finish. The chords when she sings "it's a perfect sin" are what got me on this one.
16. Deerhoof "Matchbook Seeks Maniac" (Friend Opportunity, 09)
It's amazing, the hoof can do no wrong. My favorite part is at about 2:40, when the song kinda chills out for a second, but you know the drums are just about to come back in, which they do, puncuated by a delicious single snare hit at 2:45 right before the guitar and chorus come crashing back.
17. Kelley Stoltz "Let's Go Out Tonight" (The Sun Comes Through, 04)
This song is just waiting for somebody to put it in a movie or an ad for something. Nice guitar work and cool effected harmonica solo, but the lyrics and the insistent single note bass/piano really make this one.
18. Monade "Becoming" (A Few Steps More, 07)
Laetitia from Stereolab's side project. Two distinct parts, the second of which got me with its dreamy backwards drift sound, floating off into the aether.
18.5. Triangle "The Results" (*, 01) [tape version only]
A bouncy little ditty with nice vocals.

















